Interesting, but from a Tolkienian interpretation there is no strong reason to conclude they would be more affected by nuclear fallout, because their aversion to sunlight is likely symbolic and supernatural rather than a consequence of radiation sensitivity.
Yes. From inside Tolkien’s world, Orcs’ sunlight sensitivity is simply part of how reality works. The question is not whether it’s “supernatural” or “natural,” but what mechanism causes it.
If Orcs are sensitive to sunlight because of biological traits (e.g., poor pigmentation, defective DNA repair, unusual physiology), then they might also be more vulnerable to ionizing radiation from nuclear fallout.
If their sensitivity is due to their corruption or some unique property of sunlight in Arda’s metaphysics, then there may be little or no connection to nuclear radiation.
Since Tolkien never explains the mechanism, the answer depends on how you interpret Orcs’ sunlight sensitivity. Also, Orcs are impaired by daylight, but Tolkien does not describe them suffering symptoms typical of extreme UV damage, which suggests the effect is not simply biological UV sensitivity.
Interesting, but from a Tolkienian interpretation there is no strong reason to conclude they would be more affected by nuclear fallout, because their aversion to sunlight is likely symbolic and supernatural rather than a consequence of radiation sensitivity.
Wouldn’t it only seem supernatural to us here outside the story, whereas to them inside of it, it would be entirely natural?
Therefore it may depend on how that sensitivity was implemented. (Both within and without the story.)
Yes. From inside Tolkien’s world, Orcs’ sunlight sensitivity is simply part of how reality works. The question is not whether it’s “supernatural” or “natural,” but what mechanism causes it.
If Orcs are sensitive to sunlight because of biological traits (e.g., poor pigmentation, defective DNA repair, unusual physiology), then they might also be more vulnerable to ionizing radiation from nuclear fallout.
If their sensitivity is due to their corruption or some unique property of sunlight in Arda’s metaphysics, then there may be little or no connection to nuclear radiation.
Since Tolkien never explains the mechanism, the answer depends on how you interpret Orcs’ sunlight sensitivity. Also, Orcs are impaired by daylight, but Tolkien does not describe them suffering symptoms typical of extreme UV damage, which suggests the effect is not simply biological UV sensitivity.