A massive supply chain attack targeting the Arch User Repository (AUR) has compromised more than 400 community-maintained packages, with attackers injecting malicious build scripts designed to deploy credential-stealing malware and rootkit-style payloads on affected Linux systems.
Expecting user to inspect install scripts is retarded. And this is the result.
Then dont use arch and the aur easy as that
So what would the alternative be? If the resources or desire don’t exist to make a package official, how else would you install it?
You’re missing the point entirely. I’m talking about inspecting the scripts not about making packages
Sorry if I was unclear. You usually don’t inspect the install scripts for official packages since you put the trust in the official team. You don’t trust(or at least shouldn’t) AUR packages, hence you should inspect the install script for those packages. I don’t really see what the alternative would be.
Well, the alternative would be for moderation team to inspect them, with clear signaling of which scripts are trusted and which aren’t.
But this is exactly what the top comment of Cease talks about: There is no moderation team. You seem to think that it is the job of the maintainers of the Arch Linux distribution is to vet and review the AUR packages. But they take care for the - much more widely used - Arch distro packages and are busy with this. They have enough to do. And the AUR packages are not part of the Arch distro.
The AUR is basically a server where users can store their own packages so that others can use it. As its name says: Arch User Repository.
And that’s why it’s fundamentally shit idea on so many levels. Instead of having one person to inspect let’s make every single user expert or not to inspect every package each individually. This is fucking retardation at its finest.
But who would do that? Do you have security expertise and are volunteering to do that?
Exactly. Let’s also not forget it isn’t just a matter of inspecting it once, it would be for EVERY update of the script. It would be a major bottleneck to get updates out for any package. There are comments on the AUR site where people can flag issues, so we do have some crowd sourcing, but I’d still not trust it.
The option is to not have it